You know that feeling when December 1st rolls around and you’re staring at an empty advent calendar thinking “What the heck am I supposed to put in this thing?”
I’ve been there.
In fact, when I first started making advent calendars for my family, I’d scramble around the house looking for 24 tiny items that would fit in those little pockets.
The result? A weird mix of random office supplies and expired candy.
Not exactly the magical Christmas countdown I was going for.
But here’s the thing:
After years of trial and error (and lots of feedback from disappointed kids), I’ve cracked the code on what to put in the advent calendar.
And today, as a professional custom advent calendar printing manufacturer, I’m going to share EVERYTHING I’ve learned.
Why Advent Calendar Fillers Matter More Than You Think
Here’s something most people don’t realize:
The items you put in your advent calendar can make or break your entire holiday season.
Think about it:
Your advent calendar sets the tone for December. It’s literally the first thing your family experiences each morning for 24 days straight.
Get it right? You’ve got happy kids (or adults) starting their day with excitement.
Get it wrong? You’re dealing with disappointment before breakfast.
I learned this lesson the hard way back in 2019. I threw together a last-minute advent calendar filled with whatever I could find at the dollar store.
The result?
My kids opened day one, found a generic eraser, and asked if they could just have chocolate instead.
Ouch.
That’s when I realized: advent calendar fillers aren’t just random small items. They’re tiny daily doses of joy that build anticipation for Christmas.
The 3 Types of Advent Calendar Fillers That Actually Work
After filling dozens of advent calendars over the years, I’ve discovered that the best fillers fall into three main categories:
1. Experience-Based Fillers
These are my personal favorite.
Why?
Because they create memories instead of clutter.
For example:
- Movie night coupons
- Baking cookies together vouchers
- Christmas light tour tickets
- Hot chocolate date cards
I started incorporating these in 2021, and the response was AMAZING. My family actually looked forward to opening the calendar more for the activities than the physical gifts.
2. Practical Small Gifts
These are items people actually use (unlike that random eraser I mentioned earlier).
Think:
- Lip balm
- Fun socks
- Mini hand sanitizers
- Hair ties
- Bookmarks
The key here is to choose practical items with a festive twist. Regular socks? Boring. Socks with reindeer on them? Instant win.
3. Consumable Treats
Let’s be honest:
Sometimes you just want chocolate.
But consumable treats go way beyond candy. I’m talking about:
- Specialty tea bags
- Hot chocolate bombs
- Gourmet popcorn packets
- Mini cookies
- Fruit snacks
Pro tip: Mix healthy options with treats. It prevents sugar overload and adds variety.
Age-Specific Advent Calendar Ideas That Never Fail
One size does NOT fit all when it comes to advent calendars.
What works for a toddler will bore a teenager. And what excites a teen might confuse grandma.
Here’s exactly what to put in advent calendars for different age groups:
For Toddlers (Ages 2-5)
Toddlers are actually the easiest to please. They get excited about EVERYTHING.
Winners include:
- Stickers (Christmas themed = bonus points)
- Bath crayons
- Small toy cars
- Finger puppets
- Bubbles
- Play dough
- Board books
- Crayons
- Temporary tattoos
The trick with toddlers? Keep it simple and colorful.
For Kids (Ages 6-12)
This age group wants a mix of fun and “grown-up” items.
Try these:
- Pokémon cards
- Lego minifigures
- Friendship bracelets
- Erasers (but cool ones)
- Keychains
- Small puzzles
- Craft supplies
- Gaming gift cards
- Movie tickets
For Teens (Ages 13-18)
Teenagers are tricky. But I’ve found these work consistently:
- Phone accessories
- Nail polish
- Face masks
- Gift cards (even $5 ones)
- Earbuds
- Scrunchies
- Lip gloss
- Spotify/Apple Music codes
- Coffee shop cards
For Adults
Yes, adults love advent calendars too!
Popular options:
- Wine samples
- Coffee pods
- Luxury chocolates
- Bath bombs
- Candles
- Lottery tickets
- Beauty samples
- Tea selections
- Craft beer
Budget-Friendly Advent Calendar Fillers Under $2
Here’s the truth:
Filling 24 pockets gets expensive FAST.
But you don’t need to break the bank. Some of my most successful advent calendar fillers cost less than a cup of coffee.
My favorite budget finds:
- Dollar store puzzles
- Homemade coupons
- Printed jokes or riddles
- DIY bookmarks
- Paper snowflakes
- Christmas coloring pages
- Candy canes
- Hair elastics
- Pencils
- Erasers
Pro tip: Buy multipacks and split them up. A pack of 10 hair ties becomes 10 different advent calendar gifts.
DIY Advent Calendar Fillers That Save Money
Want to cut costs even more?
Make your own fillers.
I started doing this in 2022 when inflation hit hard. And guess what? The homemade items were often MORE popular than store-bought ones.
Easy DIY options:
- Origami stars
- Handwritten notes
- Photo memories
- Homemade cookies
- Custom coupons
- Paper crafts
- Friendship bracelets
- Painted rocks
- Bookmark designs
The best part? These personalized touches make your advent calendar feel extra special.
Non-Candy Advent Calendar Ideas for Health-Conscious Families
Let’s address the elephant in the room:
Not everyone wants 24 days of sugar.
If you’re trying to keep things healthy, here are advent calendar fillers that skip the sweets:
- Dried fruit packets
- Nuts and seeds
- Veggie straws
- Cheese sticks
- Granola bars
- Rice cakes
- Trail mix
- Applesauce pouches
- Fruit leather
Mix these with non-food items for the perfect balance.
Creative Advent Calendar Themes
Here’s a next-level strategy:
Theme your entire advent calendar.
Instead of random items, create a cohesive experience. Some themes that work brilliantly:
Book Advent Calendar
24 Christmas books (mix new and wrapped library books)
Activity Advent Calendar
Daily festive activities and family experiences
Craft Advent Calendar
Supplies for 24 different Christmas crafts
LEGO Advent Calendar
Individual LEGO pieces that build into something special by Christmas Eve
Beauty Advent Calendar
Skincare samples, nail polish, and beauty treats
The Ultimate Advent Calendar Shopping List
Ready to shop? Here’s your complete checklist organized by where to find items:
Dollar Store Finds:
- Stickers
- Small toys
- Craft supplies
- Hair accessories
- School supplies
Grocery Store:
- Candy
- Tea bags
- Hot chocolate packets
- Granola bars
- Fruit snacks
Online:
- Mini figures
- Bulk items
- Specialty treats
- Experience vouchers
- Unique small gifts
Craft Store:
- Beads
- Stamps
- Washi tape
- Mini ornaments
- Craft kits
Common Advent Calendar Mistakes to Avoid
After years of advent calendar fails, here are the mistakes I see people make:
Mistake #1: Buying everything last minute
Prices skyrocket in December. Start shopping in October.
Mistake #2: Forgetting about size constraints
Measure your pockets first. Trust me on this one.
Mistake #3: Not mixing it up
24 pieces of candy = boring by day 10.
Mistake #4: Ignoring dietary restrictions
Always check for allergies and preferences.
Mistake #5: Overcomplicating it
Simple items often bring the most joy.
How to Personalize Your Advent Calendar
Want to make your advent calendar extra special?
Personalization is key.
Here’s how:
- Include inside jokes
- Add photos
- Reference favorite memories
- Include their favorite treats
- Create custom coupons
- Write personal notes
These small touches transform a generic countdown into a meaningful tradition.
Pro Tips for Advent Calendar Success
After filling literally hundreds of advent pockets, here are my top tips:
Tip #1: Prep everything in November
Wrap items, label days, and store in a box.
Tip #2: Keep a master list
Track what goes in each pocket to ensure variety.
Tip #3: Have backup items
Kids lose things. Adults forget. Have extras ready.
Tip #4: Mix big and small
Alternate between exciting and simple items.
Tip #5: End strong
Make day 24 extra special.
Final Thoughts
Here’s the bottom line:
What to put in the advent calendar doesn’t have to be complicated or expensive.
The best advent calendars combine thoughtful small gifts, fun experiences, and occasional treats to create 24 days of joy.
Whether you’re filling pockets for toddlers or adults, the key is variety and personalization.
Start planning early, shop smart, and remember: it’s not about perfection. It’s about creating a daily moment of happiness during the busy holiday season.
Your family won’t remember every single item. But they WILL remember the excitement of counting down to Christmas together.
And that’s what really matters.
English 
German 
French